Home > Browse Secrets > The Catcher In The Rye

The Catcher In The Rye

Posted by an anonymous user on 4/29/2010 3:46:00 PM (Report abuse)
Has anyone else here read it? Did it move you in any way? If yes, which bits did you particularly enjoy/feel moved by? Thank you.

Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post.
I read it not long ago. Its a really really good book. I related to him so much, it kind of scares me. For example, when he talks about fake people, and the actors theory, that you can't enjoy the movie because you know the actors know they are good actors, it sucks the good out of the movie because its all fake. It is a really depressing book though, perhaps because it tells the truth exactly the way it is. The guy is a good kid, shown by how he gets a prostitute, but doesn't do anything but pays her anyways. Also like he only relates to kids and the reason he is so messed up is because his brother who was a really innocent person died, the one person he looked up to. PLUS!! I know im gushing about this book, but omg like the title is amazing!!!! He's the catcher because he wants to be the person who saves the kids from going over the cliff. I cried too much over this book. But the ending was really blunt.
This is the kind of author I wish I could have a coffee with and talk with, too bad he's gone, but he was really definitly talented. :)
Posted by safetynet on 4/29/2010 7:11:00 PM (Report abuse)
I'm almost at the end of it, it's quite interesting hearing the thoughts of someone like Holden Caulfield, going on about random things sometimes that have nothing to do with what's occuring in the present, it sounds like something I would do if I were the main character in a story, and the best part is that something like that sounds so realistic, just travling through New York, and all the things he was thinking about, and how he didn't feel like doing some things sometimes, it sounds a bit like what I would do. Did you know that the author, J.D. Salinger, died recently, it's kind of sad knowing that he's the author of such a classic, I wish they'd make a movie of it, but somehow, I don't know if it would be exciting enough, and even they did, people are going to make a lot of comparisons between the book and the movie, and they would want it to be precise, but knowing the movie industry, they'd probably cut out a lot just for time's sake, although if they make it like three hours long or so, kinda like Watchmen, it'd get a lot of it in, but it probably won't be very exciting due to the fact that what Holden was going through could happen to anyone and I'm sure a lot of people would compare themselves to him, but the majority of the public would just think it's boring because it's so realistic, and people prefer the impossible things that happen in chick flicks that are so unrealistic and that it sets peoples expectations rather high, because nothing ever happens like that in reality, sure there are a few people who've had certain events happen to them, but that's the exception, the majority of the population would be the rule. You'd pretty much know that if you've ever seen He's Just Not That Into You and 500 Days of Summer, I think J.D. Sallinger knows what he's talking about when he portrays Holden Caulfield like that in that kind of storyline, to show that all the actors in the movie industry are the reasons why men like me have had their hearts broken so many times, because we expect reality to be like it is in the movies and we imagine ourselves to be the main protagonist in order to provide stimulation, so we go to these movies because our lives aren't exciting enough, because it's not reality and we want things to go our way, that's just it, we just want things to go our way. Well, I think I've ranted enough here, it's nice to find someone who appreciates literature like I do.
Posted by SilverSheilds on 4/29/2010 4:14:00 PM (Report abuse)
MisterMinutehand, I am writing an essay :) I thought it was quite a good and "realistic" portrayal of teenage rebellion and stupidity! Haha.

Andrew, you should give it a read sometime. You'll undoubtedly enjoy it!

Loucipher, did you enjoy it? :D
Posted by an anonymous user on 4/29/2010 3:59:00 PM (Report abuse)
I went to high school, so yes, I did.
It was the most beautiful thing I had to read for American lit.
But the most enjoyable part of the book was the knowledge that Holden was probably lying about everything that happened, that his life isn't that exciting, that he's just a troubled kid trying to sound exciting.
Posted by FinderOfPeace on 4/29/2010 3:57:00 PM (Report abuse)
SPOILER

I bought the book in 9th grade on my own. I still have it. It's an interesting book. I didn't relate to him, but I was on his side. It didn't really move me...but the parts I enjoyed were when his teacher tries to make a move on him, and the whole bit about the pimp and prostitute.
Posted by FUNNY on 4/29/2010 3:56:00 PM (Report abuse)
have i ever read it?? HOLDEN CAULFIELD.....
Posted by loucipher on 4/29/2010 3:54:00 PM (Report abuse)
Are you writing an essay? I haven't read it in years, and it was ruined by my teacher's long winded attempts at showing us all the allusions that the text is full of.

I enjoyed it. I remember feeling very at ease in Holden's narrations, even if he were a bit of a rebellious and stupid teenager. I was a bit rebellious and stupid at the time, too, so I related.

I don't remember the specifics very well.
Posted by MisterMinutehand on 4/29/2010 3:48:00 PM (Report abuse)
I want to read it but haven't yet
Posted by Andrew on 4/29/2010 3:47:00 PM (Report abuse)

Leave your comments

Comment as an anonymous user or Login.


© SecretTalk.com all rights reserved.